This release couples Skrowaczewski’s previous Schumann Symphonies 1 & 4 with a new disc of Nos. 2 & 3 to complete the cycle. Like Nos. 1 & 4 (type Q11783 in Search Reviews), Skrowaczewski’s brisk tempos, clear phrasing, and light textures result in some wonderfully refreshing Schumann. Symphony No. 2 is the best of the cycle–a really bracing account that crackles with energy from start to finish. It brings to mind Sinopoli’s exciting Vienna recording for Deutsche Grammophon (not his disappointing Dresden remake), and it’s notable that, even without the Vienna Philharmonic’s heft and sheen, the Deutsche Radio Philharmonie delivers an idiomatic and handsomely played performance.
Symphony No. 3 launches boldly with a Lebhaft movement that lives up to its title (“lively”). Skrowaczewski’s keen focus and tight control make for a clearly argued development that in lesser hands can sound like an episodic muddle. After this, the conductor’s traditionally-paced Scherzo sounds a bit labored by comparison. So it comes as a happy surprise that Skrowaczewski pulls out all the stops for the Finale (another Lebhaft), turning it from a gentlemanly discussion to a vigorous debate with a truly rousing conclusion (although brass fans might grumble at his diminishing the big chorale at points so that the string and wind accompaniments can be clearly heard). It all adds up to a compelling pair of performances, and makes the set as whole one of the more interesting and desirable on the market. The warm, spacious recording seals the deal. Highly recommended. [7/9/2009]
