This is a novel and fortuitous pairing on disc. Chausson and Tchaikovsky actually composed their piano trios within months of each other (the former in autumn of 1881, the latter in the winter of 1881/82), and while they both begin in a similar somber atmosphere, stylistically they are worlds apart. Harmonically, Chausson’s early work (Op. 5) is clearly the more forward-looking and experimental. The opening theme (which is followed by a passionately flowing allegro) returns at the start of the slow third movement, comprising just one of the cyclic devices Chausson employs throughout the work. As a whole, the piece is highly emotional (you were expecting something else from Chausson?) and quite moving, though it is also very satisfying in a formal sense with its carefully planned structure and brilliant instrumental writing. These qualities are effectively illustrated by the marvelous playing of the Yuval Trio, who also turn in a tour-de-force performance of the Tchaikovsky.
Going beyond surface virtuosity, the Yuval lives the music inside-out, applying a rubato that is at once original and seemingly inevitable. This is particularly so in the first movement’s E major second subject, introduced with less ardor than the Ashkenazy Trio on Naxos but with a compensating grandeur, poetry, and beauty of tone. These qualities make for a stimulating and memorable performance, one that makes you regret that the ensemble disbanded in 1994. The recordings, made in 1989 and 1990, evoke a natural sound setting that places the players believably in your listening room. A piano trio disc not to be missed.
